Editorial: Biological xenophobia

From ANIMAL PEOPLE, December 1996:

Our friend Bob Plumb, of the Promoting Animal Welfare Society, in Paradise,
California, recently became aware of a feral cat problem at a park in nearby Chico. A large
colony was accused of killing songbirds, and slated for destruction by animal control.
Plumb, a retired physics teacher, combines his longtime philanthropic interest in
humane work with applied math skills. He especially likes to solve problems through modeling,
projecting the outcome of various strategies based on known statistical parameters
––and over the years, he’s become rather good at it.
When Plumb worked out the numbers pertaining to the park in Chico, he found
that the popular approach, trying to catch and kill all the cats, wouldn’t work. Catch-andkill
capture efficiency, in that habitat, stood little chance of exceeding the reproduction
rate. In effect, using catch-and-kill would amount to farming cats, sending each season’s
“crop” off to slaughter just in time to open hunting territory to the next round of kittens.
The benefit to birds would be nil.
Plumb also modeled neuter/release, which he calls TTAVR, short for trap/treat
(for treatable medical conditions)/alter/vaccinate/release, to cover all steps. Adoptable cats
would be put up for adoption; seriously ill or injured cats would be euthanized.
The first-year costs, he found, would be far greater, since neutering a cat costs
about five times as much as killing the cat and disposing of the remains. Over a three-year
period, however, the costs would be the same, as the neutered park cats ceased breeding.

Read more

Police recorded early MOVE animal actions

From ANIMAL PEOPLE, November 1996:

PHILADELPHIA––Philadelphia
police surveillance records and a Philadelphia
Daily News clipping provided to ANIMAL
PEOPLE on September 27 by Arlette Liewer
of Den Hague, The Netherlands, document
that the Afro-American activist commune
MOVE held at least nine demonstrations presaging
the animal rights movement between
July 1973 and September 1974.
Most of the animal-related MOVE
protests came within days of the publication of
the books Man Kind?, by Cleveland Amory,
and Animal Liberation, by Peter Singer,
which are generally recognized as the founding
documents of the animal rights movement,
as distinguished from the ancestor humane,
antivivisection, and animal welfare movements.
Amory founded The Fund for Animals
later in 1974.

Read more

THE POWER OF ONE: HOW THE INDIVIDUAL ACTIVIST CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE

From ANIMAL PEOPLE, October 1996:

by Henry Spira (founder and president, Animal Rights International)

Today’s animal rights
organizations are numerous and
powerful. More than ever before,
they are well-financed, politically
connected, with their own legal,
advertising, and public relations
departments. Enormous direct mail
campaigns are routine.
One may well ask what
role, if any, remains for the committed
individual, who has no apparatus
or financial backing. It may be
encouraging to remember that it was
an individual’s initiative, Peter
Singer’s book Animal Liberation,
that 22 years ago launched the modern
animal rights movement.
Few of us can write a book
with global influence, but with
knowledge, imagination, and commitment,
many individuals can
make a difference. Not every
activist’s initiative needs to make the
evening news. Rather, it is the accumulation
of smaller actions by individuals
that has made animal rights
the mainstream concept it is today.

Read more

ALF RAIDS KILL ANIMALS

From ANIMAL PEOPLE, August/September 1996:

Animal Liberation Front actions
reportedly caused the deaths at least 3,000
animals in the first half of 1996, including
2,000 pregnant mink who were roadkilled
or starved about six months before they
would have been pelted, after 3,000 were
released from the L.W. Bennett & Sons fur
farm near East Bloomfield, New York, on
April 4. Late snow cut their already slim
chances of finding adequate wild prey.
According to the Memphis-based
Coalition to Abolish the Fur Trade, which
claims to speak for the ALF, “more than
11,000 animals have been freed during the
past 10 months,” but except for the New
York action, most––almost all mink––were
recaptured on or near the fur farms.

Read more

ACTIVISTS IN ACTION

From ANIMAL PEOPLE, August/September 1996:

The trial of Mary Constantine and
Bobbi Rhud of Minnetonkans Against Animal
Cruelty for allegedly interfering in a deer cull by
videotaping it ended June 24 with a hung jury.
Constantine and Rhud were arrested in an apparent
ambush on February 19, along with Steve Hindi,
president of the Chicago Animal Rights Coalition,
after retrieving hidden cameras and returning to
Hindi’s van. Minnetonka police spent several days
checking out Hindi’s electronic equipment before
returning it all to him, under court order, with rundown
batteries. All charges against Hindi were
dropped just before the trial. Hindi attended anyway,
as a defense witness. “The police really
helped,” he said. “One cop described the layout of
the ‘getaway’ van––even the back seats, quite an
accomplishment, since there weren’t any. Police
photographs proved that. The police were caught in
so many lies that the prosecutior repeatedly apologized
to the jury for their ‘mistaken’ testimony in his
final argument. The jury was apparently hung
because one juror, a bow hunter, was bent on conviction
from the beginning, telling other jurors he
‘wasn’t particularly concerned’ that the cops lied.”

Read more

Editorial: Who got the March money?

From ANIMAL PEOPLE, August/September 1996:

Observers of the June 23 March for the Animals in Washington D.C. and the preceding
World Animal Awareness Week may be reminded of The Producers, the 1968 Zero
Mostel/Gene Wilder film about two schemers who persuade an outlandish number of
investors to fund a deliberate Broadway flop. The idea is to fail so miserably that all
investors assume their money is lost, and don’t ask embarrassing questions. Mostel and
Wilder stage the most tasteless musical script they can find, called Springtime for
Hitler––only to have it succeed as a farce, sending them to Sing-Sing when the investors
ask for their promised cuts of the gate, adding up to far more than 100%.
But the March was no surprise success. And it might embarrass the cause of animal
protection less if it was in fact a fraud instead of just a public failure.

Read more

HYPERACTIVISM: THE PHENOMENON OF DOING WITHOUT ACHIEVING

From ANIMAL PEOPLE, June 1996:

by Henry Spira

While recognizing that
most people care deeply about the
well-being of animals, it’s crucial to
remember that right thought and
right speech, by themselves, are not
enough. For activists who want to
make a difference, thinking must be
linked with doing.
But for some time the animal
rights movement has been
trapped in the nightmare in which
you run as hard as possible, yet
can’t move forward. For all its
growing resources and considerable
energy, the movement is barely
scratching the surface of animal suffering
and misery.
This is a tragedy given the
remarkable progress made in the
1970s and 1980s, when activists
convinced society that animal suffering
matters. Polls now suggest that
more than 95% of Americans care
about the well-being of animals.

Read more

Was MOVE an animal rights group?

From ANIMAL PEOPLE, May 1996:

PHILADELPHIA––Jury
selection began April 2 for the
trial of MOVE activist
Ramona Africa’s damage suit
against the city of
Philadelphia.
Ramona Africa and her 13-
year-old son Birdie were the
sole survivors of the May 13,
1985 bombing by Philadelphia
police of the MOVE
headquarters, ending a 90-
minute siege during which the
police fired an estimated
10,000 rounds. MOVE members
had two pistols, two
shotguns, and a .22 rifle. Six
adults and five children were
killed; 61 homes burned.
The siege is widely noted
as a landmark in the history of
Afro-American militant conflict
with authority. Recent
accounts have often added the
claim that MOVE had an
“animal rights” orientation.
From the April 2 edition of
The New York Times:
“MOVE, an interracial
group founded in the early
1970s around the issues of
animal rights and police
brutality, preaches a backto-nature
life.”
The source of this information
seems to be Ramona
Africa herself, who has
claimed in recent writings
and lectures s that MOVE
was vegetarian and animal –
oriented. In an e-mail to
ANIMAL PEOPLE, she
claimed MOVE in the
1970s led demonstrations,
purportedly violently repressed
by police, against
Canadian sealing, the
Philadelphia Zoo and
b a b o o n – h e a d – c r u s h i n g
experiments at the University
of Pennsylvania. She
also claimed MOVE
founder John Africa “did
more to stop dogfighting in
Rochester, New York,
than anybody else up
there,” without citing
specifics as to when or
how.
Elaborating, MOVE
supporter Marpessa Kupendua
said MOVE had a “20-
year history of getting their
asses kicked while protesting
at zoos, circuses, and pet
stores,” and alleged online
that, “Dick Gregory stole his
entire [vegetarian] health
empire from the writings of
John Africa.”
However, A N I M A L
PEOPLE has so far found no
confirmation of these claims in
sources predating the bombing
• The electronic archives
of the Philadelphia Inquirer
and the Philadelphia Daily
News include extensive coverage
of MOVE, which was
locally prominent for more
than a decade before the
bombing, and was involved in
a 1978 shootout that killed a
police officer; nine MOVE
members drew 30 years to life
in prison. The only animalrelated
coverage, however,
pertains to neighbors’ complaints
about apparent animalcollecting,
which Ramona
Africa describes as rescuing,
involving the accumulation of
unneutered, un-vaccinated
dogs in filthy conditions.
• Contemporary animal
rights literature takes no notice
of MOVE, even in seeking
Afro-American links. T h e
Animals’ Agenda m a g a z i n e
apparently never mentioned
MOVE, despite the interest of
longtime staffers in cause linkage
and racial justice.
• Nothing about MOVE
appears in histories of animal
rights activism, including the
works of Rod Preece and
Lorna Chamberlain, David
Helvarg, Rik Scarce, Richard
Ryder, Lawrence and Susan
Finsen, James Jasper and
Dorothy Nelkin, and Andrew
Rowan.
• The extensive ANIMAL
P E O P L E files on the head
injury lab protests and on the
Philadelphia Zoo include nothing
mentioning MOVE.
• Anti-animal rights literature,
which seldom misses a
chance to link animal rights
views with fanaticism, takes
no notice of MOVE, either.
• MOVE did not rate a
mention in the 1993 U.S.
Department of Justice Report
on Animal Rights Terrorism.
Ambiguous references linking
MOVE to some animal
rights concerns were included
in a 1987 book about the
bombing, Burning Down The
House, by John Anderson and

Wise-use wiseguys

From ANIMAL PEOPLE, May 1996:

Putting People First was reportedly set to link
Unabomber suspect Theodore Kaczynski, Earth First!, and
animal rights activism at an early-April press conference in
Montana––but the Unabomber’s manifesto, published last year
by The New York Times, described animal rights activists as
delusionary; the San Jose Mercury-News on April 8 published an
interview with Jo Ann DeYoung, a former high school classmate
of Kaczynski, who remembered that he once slipped the
pelt of a dissected cat into her locker; and on April 10 The New
York Times published letters Kacynski wrote to a friend, describing
how he hunted rabbits. Kacynski’s brother David, who
turned the suspect in to the FBI, was meanwhile described by
The New York Times as a vegetarian “bunny-hugger.” PPF cancelled
the press conference, allegedly because it received anonymous
threats but couldn’t get police protection. The purported
Earth First! link was made, however, on April 9 by ABC World
News Tonight. Kacynski had no known association with Earth
First! itself, but of the three people killed and 23 hurt in the 17-
year string of Unabomber attacks, two victims worked for firms
named on a “hit list” issued in 1992 by Live Wild Or Die,
newsletter of a splinter group led by Mike Jakubal, which broke
away in 1989, after Earth First! renounced tree-spiking. The list
was in fact the list of co-sponsors of a 1989 wise-use conference.

Read more

1 32 33 34 35 36 48