BOOKS: The Moral Menagerie: Philosophy and Animal Rights
From ANIMAL PEOPLE, May 2007:
The Moral Menagerie: Philosophy and Animal Rights
by Marc R. Fellenz
Univ. of Illinois Press
(1325 S. Oak St., Champaign, IL 61820), 2007.
301 pages, paperback. $25.00
Marc Fellenz, a philosophy teacher at
Suffolk County Community College in New York,
writes from a broader and deeper perspective than
is typical in debates over animal rights theory.
Reviewing the major animal rights theories,
Fellenz fails to find any that lack significant
shortcomings. He goes on to look for a better
intellectual basis on which to ground an ethical
theory on behalf of animals.
Fellenz rejects Peter Singer’s
utilitarianism because one cannot weigh the
benefits of most activities against the costs
with any precision.